Italy fined Meta €805 million on Saturday after finding that Facebook reached into the photo galleries of Android users in the country without their specific consent.
The penalty is the largest the Italian regulator has ever imposed. It turns on a plain question: when a phone asks for access to your photos, does that permission also cover a feature that reads those photos to suggest posts? Rome’s answer is no, and the ruling gives Meta 60 days to change how the feature works.
Key Points
- Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million (about $887 million) on 14 November 2026.
- At issue is a Facebook tool that pulls pictures and clips from a person’s own gallery and puts them forward as possible posts.
- The Garante put the number of people caught up in it at close to 20 million Android users in Italy.
- The order gives Meta 60 days to make the feature opt-in, with consent asked for on its own. The company said it would appeal.
What happened
The tool behind the fine carries the name “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook”. It has been available since 2023. While a person scrolls through Facebook, it offers pictures and clips from the phone’s own gallery as ideas for posts.
According to the Garante, the app asked once for gallery access, under a blanket permission for the whole of Facebook. The notice shown to users did not make clear that the permission would also let Facebook read their photos to build those suggestions. It also came switched on, unless a user went in and turned it off.
The Facebook app “accessed photos, videos and associated metadata stored on Italian users’ smartphones without specific consent and without informing them”, the authority said.
The regulator said the practice broke Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, the provision that puts Europe’s ePrivacy rules into Italian law. Those rules treat the contents of a person’s phone as part of their private sphere, and they require free and informed consent before a company can reach into it.
The investigation began in July 2025, after a complaint from the consumer protection centre in Bolzano. It included a technical examination of the Facebook app. The fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, which argued that Italy had no jurisdiction. The Garante rejected that argument, saying the ePrivacy rules do not provide for the European Union’s one-stop-shop system, under which a company answers mainly to the regulator in the country where it is based.
Why it matters
Scale is the first reason. The fine equals about 0.47 percent of Meta’s global revenue, and the regulator said roughly 20 million Android users in Italy could have been affected. The Garante said Meta’s lack of cooperation during the investigation and an earlier violation, which drew a fine in 2019, both pushed the figure higher.
The ruling also draws a line that reaches beyond one feature. Permission granted for one purpose does not stretch to another, and a setting switched on by default is not the same as a choice. That reading will matter to every app that asks for access to a phone’s photos, contacts or files and then finds new uses for them.
One question the case deliberately left alone is artificial intelligence. Whether the gallery material fed any AI training was outside the investigation; Meta says it did not. The Garante said it would keep the right to examine separately a newer feature, launched in 2026, that sends gallery content to the cloud for processing. No date was given for that review.
The timing adds weight. Meta has spent the past year adding AI features that handle personal material, including its Muse assistant, which remembers earlier conversations with a user. And the argument over what AI software may do with personal data is running in parallel elsewhere: OpenAI launched ChatGPT Wallet this week, letting its agents pay for online shopping. Regulators in Europe and the United States are now testing the same boundary from different sides.
Italy is not the only place where Meta’s handling of personal data has drawn a large penalty. A New Mexico judge set the payment at $25 billion on 21 October, after jurors found the company had misled people in the state over how their data was handled. The case traces back to the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Meta said it would appeal that ruling too.
What happens next for Meta in Italy
Within 60 days, Meta must turn the gallery tool off by default and put a separate request to Italian users, one that spells out why the access is needed and how to turn it off. The company told the BBC it would appeal, saying: “We strongly disagree with the [regulator’s] assessment of the facts, its application of the law, and the disproportionate level of the fine.”
Meta’s position is that the feature is straightforward and that people must grant permission on their device before it can work. The Garante’s finding is that the device permission alone was not enough, because users were never told what the permission would be used for. That disagreement is now the ground of the appeal.
For Italian users, nothing changes at once. The feature stays as it is until Meta makes the change or a court rules otherwise. The next step to watch is the Garante’s separate review of the cloud version of the feature, which could bring a second decision.
Sources: Reuters, Al Jazeera, BBC, NDTV. Published: 15 November 2026.



