Seven Republican senators are pressing to delay Tuesday’s vote on the party’s Senate leadership, arguing the conference must first face up to its midterm losses before choosing who leads it into the minority.
Key Points
- Seven Republican senators want Tuesday’s Senate leadership elections delayed.
- Sen. Ron Johnson’s letter, signed by four colleagues, calls a rushed vote “political malpractice” after a “stunning defeat”.
- Sen. Rick Scott is withholding support for John Thune until a lame-duck agenda is laid out.
- Thune is running unopposed and has led the conference since January 2025.
- The vote is set for 9 a.m. Tuesday in the Old Senate Chamber by secret ballot; the call on a delay rests with Sen. Tom Cotton.
What happened in the Thune leadership vote fight
Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, is leading the push. On Monday he sent a letter to Sen. Tom Cotton of Arkansas, the Senate Republican Conference chair, asking that the leadership elections be put off until the conference has met to discuss what went wrong on 3 November.
Four colleagues signed the letter with him: Sens. Rick Scott of Florida, Mike Lee of Utah, Ted Budd of North Carolina and John Kennedy of Louisiana. That gives the group the five signatures conference rules require to force a meeting of the full conference, which Policy Committee Chair Shelley Moore Capito must then call.
Two more senators have backed the delay without signing. Sen. Dave McCormick of Pennsylvania wrote on Sunday that he did not believe the party should move to leadership elections “until we have digested and debated the lessons of the midterms and how to move forward”. Sen. Jim Banks of Indiana has said the same, bringing the public total to seven.
The sharpest new pressure came from Scott on Tuesday. In an interview with Fox News Digital, he said he was not ready to back Thune for another term as the party’s Senate leader unless whoever leads lays out a plan for passing key agenda items in the lame-duck session, before Democrats take control of the chamber in January.
“I don’t want to put the cart before the horse,” Scott said. “I mean, I think the first step is what do we want to accomplish? And then anybody, including John Thune, if they want to be that, the first thing I have to say is, ‘Do they want to do that?'”
Scott also made clear he would not run for the job himself. He has tried twice before, against Mitch McConnell in 2022 and again when the party chose McConnell’s successor in 2024. Asked whether he wanted someone else to jump in, he said: “Oh, I wouldn’t do that to anybody.”
Johnson’s letter is blunt about the stakes. It describes last Tuesday’s result as a “stunning defeat” and argues that voting on a leadership team without a thorough review of it would be “political malpractice”. His group wants leadership candidates to explain how they would govern from the minority and how they would confront the incoming Democratic majority.
Why the Thune leadership vote matters
Thune, a Republican from South Dakota, has led the Senate Republican Conference since January 2025. He plans to seek another term and, so far, faces no declared challenger. If he wins on Tuesday, he would lead the party’s senators into the minority when Democrats take over in January, after voters handed Democrats both chambers of Congress.
The revolt is a measure of how raw the midterm result still is inside the party. Democrats flipped six Senate seats on 3 November, and the conference was preparing to hold a closed-door leadership election barely a week later. Two Senate races are still uncalled — in Mississippi and Alaska — so the conference’s final shape is not even settled, a point Lee has raised in arguing for a pause.
Prediction markets have noticed. On Kalshi, Thune’s odds of becoming the next Senate minority leader fell from 91 percent to 64 percent in a single day, while Johnson’s own odds climbed as high as 27 percent on Monday before settling at 14 percent. Those are betting-market odds, not a poll of senators, but the swing captures how suddenly the contest has opened up.
President Donald Trump has declined to say whether Thune should stay on as leader. That silence matters: Trump has pressed Senate leaders for months to move his agenda, including the SAVE America Act, and after the midterms he blamed the party’s failure to get measures through the Senate as one reason for the losses.
The decision on whether the vote goes ahead rests with Cotton, though such calls are normally made with leadership’s support. Axios reported that, as of Monday, the elections were still scheduled to proceed as planned by secret ballot. Unless a senator moves to delay the election and a majority backs it, the vote is expected to go forward on Tuesday morning.
What happens next in the Thune leadership vote
The conference meets on Tuesday morning, when Johnson and his allies will argue for a pause before any ballots are cast. If a majority backs a delay, the reckoning debate comes first and the vote moves. If not, senators will vote in secret, and Thune is still widely expected to keep the top job — wounded, but in place.
Either way, the fight sets the tone for the lame-duck session now under way. Congress returns with federal funding running out on 11 December and a crowded agenda, from the defence bill to the farm bill, while Democrats prepare to take over on 3 January. The leadership vote was supposed to be a formality. It has become the first test of whether the party wants to argue about what went wrong before it picks who leads it next.
Sources: Fox News, Axios, Bloomberg, The Hill, Washington Times, Roll Call, Daily Caller. Published: 10 November 2026, Kuala Lumpur time.



